Breakpoint

IVF and the Risk of Cancer

Written by Breakpoint | 11/17/26, 11:00 AM

Author: John Stonestreet and Dr. Timothy D. Padgett

A recent study out of Denmark found that the “[u]se of frozen embryo transfer was associated with a small but statistically significant increased risk for childhood cancer.” In a survey of just over 1 million births between 1996 and 2012, researchers found that cancer occurred in 44.4 out of every 100,000 born after being frozen as embryos, compared to just 17.5 out of every 100,000 born that were not frozen as embryos. In other words, children who were frozen as embryos carry more than double the risk of cancer. As the authors of the study observed: 

In this large nationwide Danish register-based cohort study, no statistically significant association was found between use of any fertility treatment, any fertility drugs, IVF, or intracytoplasmic sperm injection and cancer in children; however, children born after the use of frozen embryo transfer were at an increased risk, mainly driven by an increased risk of leukemia and sympathetic nervous system tumors. 

Some might claim that those in need of fertility treatment in the first place would carry a greater chance of passing medical problems on to their children. However, as the children rights group Them Before Us wrote in response to the study: 

The researchers checked. Women who had struggled with infertility but conceived without treatment did not see the same jump in their children’s cancer rate. The difference followed the procedure. 

Nearly all IVF procedures involve freezing at some point in the process. An article at Them Before Us summarized data reported by the Center for Disease Control: 

In 2022, 435,426 IVF cycles were performed in the United States. More than 40 percent were freeze-all cycles in which every embryo created was frozen and no transfer happened at all. Of the transfers that did take place, 86.9 percent used previously frozen embryos. 

Even under the best of conditions, IVF is a morally fraught practice. Today, it is often complicated by the inherent commodification of buying and selling babies through the practice of surrogacy. The incredibly loose laws that govern IVF and surrogacy make it horrifically easy for bad actors to acquire children and exploit vulnerable women. In many places, safety protocols are somewhere between insufficient and nonexistent. Even when the system is not abused, thousands of unborn human children are brought to life and then left to die; dozens created at a time for the intention of keeping only one or two. The rest are frozen, destroyed, or donated to medical research.  

Them Before Us has crafted a helpful series of questions entitled, “If you or someone you love is considering IVF.” The questions address concerns over the specific methods used, the number of embryos involved, and health dangers to the new lives, including the dangers highlighted in this Danish study. These questions are a great resource for understanding and communicating about the complicated ethical issues surrounding IVF.  

Too many people, especially Christians, have been quick to jump on the bandwagon of artificial reproductive technologies without fully understanding what they are and the ethical implications they carry. Too often, the otherwise natural desire to be parents justifies the means by which it happens. Many assume that if children are gifts, then it does not matter how they are acquired; or if the practice is common, it must be ethically settled. In our haste to fulfill adult desires, children are being harmed. Even if freezing embryos did not put them more at risk for cancer, it would be problematic. But now that we know, we cannot remain callous to the risks discovered in this study.