Author: John Stonestreet and Andrew Carico
C.S. Lewis was born in November 1898 and died in November 1963. A leading Christian apologist of his time and still a major authority on Christianity’s impact on all of life, Lewis dedicated much of his writing to education, especially in the essays that comprise The Abolition of Man. The opening essay of that book, “Men without Chests” is a sound critique of the then-current state of British education.
In a lesser-known short essay, “Screwtape Proposes a Toast," Lewis aims at American education. Published in 1959, the essay is a sequel to The Screwtape Letters. Both works are fictional accounts of a devil, Screwtape, who advises his nephew and tempter-in-training, Wormwood.
In this story, with a sinister toast to young devils at the annual Tempters’ Training College in Hell, Screwtape sells the benefit of twisting the meaning of the word “democracy,” from recognizing that all individuals have equal rights to requiring all individuals be equal in all respects. In this perverted reformulation, man’s envy and resentment could be activated to pull down those of exceptional talent and ability.
In essence, Screwtape hoped to inspire the emerging tempters to instill in humans the sentiments that would eliminate “every kind of human excellence—moral, cultural, social, or intellectual.” And education is the best means to achieve this end. As Uncle Screwtape says in the essay,
The basic principle of the new education is to be that dunces and idlers must not be made to feel inferior to intelligent and industrious pupils. That would be ‘undemocratic.’ These differences between pupils . . . must be disguised.
This can be done, suggests the senior devil, by ensuring that all students receive good grades on all exams, by accepting everyone who applies to universities, and by lowering academic standards. No one should believe they are “inferior.”
If this sounds familiar, it should. Educational institutions rarely challenge students to be the best they can be. Even a quick look at recent headlines tells of the decline of civic literacy amongst America’s K-12 students, the growing emphasis on “equity-based education,” reduced educational standards, and one Christian university dean claiming that belief in "Christ alone" is “white privilege.”
Equality does not mean “sameness,” a point that Thomas Jefferson, who wrote “all men are created equal,” believed. Jefferson distinguished between artificial aristocracy, based on “wealth and birth,” and natural aristocracy, based on “virtue and talents.” While all are equal in dignity, they are unequal in God-given talents and abilities. Other American statesmen, including Abraham Lincoln, heartily endorsed this truth and understood it as essential to human flourishing and national success.
When Screwtape disguises envy as “democratic,” he aims to makes it palatable, even acceptable. The result is to abolish true education and sow the seeds for universal “ignorance.” This also has impact beyond the temporal, Screwtape says:
“. . . the real end is the destruction of individuals. For only individuals can be saved or damned, can be come sons of the Enemy (God) or food for us.”
Our individual differences result from how God uniquely created us, with distinct abilities and capacities. To reject them, Screwtape says, is to be closed off to humility, charity, contentment, gratitude, admiration and “almost every road which might finally lead [someone] to Heaven.”
The Bible speaks of the differences between us and relates them to human flourishing. In Genesis, Adam saw Eve as a human being made in God’s image, but he recognized her as different and worthy of her own dignity. Ironically, in the entire history of thought, only Christianity gave us the category of human dignity. Now, in the name of human dignity, we claim that any and all differences rob us of dignity. The devil always twists what is good and attempts to use it for evil.
The purpose of education is to first “glorify God” and learn ways in which to “enjoy him forever.” In service of that vision is to learn how to flourish using the giftings He has given us. As written in Restoring All Things, a book I co-authored, “learning . . . has a telos, or a purpose. We learn so we can more fully become who we were created to be.”
Education should hold students to the highest of possible standards, honoring the unique gifts God has given them, and pointing ultimately to the author and perfector of our faith and of all knowledge, Jesus Christ.




Breakpoint